Letter 1437 published 20 November 2026
LEO XIV AND THE TRADITIONAL LITURGY:
THE DILEMMA OF A CHOICE
Appearances Can Be Deceptive. Between Francis and Leo, one pontificate follows another and, in many respects, they look alike… or so it seems. Of course, their styles, personalities, ways of being in the world and in the Church differ. No one will be surprised that there are fifty shades of exercising the supreme pontificate. But as far as substance is concerned — by which we mean the overall direction and governance — continuity between Leo and Francis is becoming increasingly evident, or at the very least, has not been disproved. More than a year and a half after his election, Leo XIV is acting as a disciple of Pope Francis’s ideas. Undoubtedly in a less abrupt manner, and therefore a more accomplished pupil, some might say with a hint of irritation.
Leo XIV, Francis’s Spiritual Son?
When it comes to the answers given aboard the papal plane during the customary press briefings on return flights from apostolic journeys, we remember the heated controversies Pope Francis sparked with his airborne remarks, whether the famous “Who am I to judge?” (July 2013) or “Good Catholics should not breed like rabbits” (January 2015), to name but two examples.
On his return flight to the Vatican following his triumphant tour of South America (Uruguay, Argentina and Peru) from 6 to 17 November, Leo XIV addressed head-on an issue that has been a source of trauma for the Church in France — the first time he had done so since his election. Asked about the burning question of freedoms regarding the ancient liturgy, and whether the severe restrictions recommended by the Motu Proprio Traditionis Custodes should be lifted or eased, the Holy Father calmly replied, with his familiar smile: “No, not for the time being. Traditionis Custodes was a decision made by Pope Francis, and we will continue to follow it.” Leo XIV justified this position in the name of “the unity of the Church”.
“Can the Church be truly and profoundly reconciled outside the unity of faith?” asked Father Barthe in his latest article, published in Res Novae – Perspectives Romaines on 6 November 2026. Jean-Pierre Maugendre (Renaissance Catholique), for his part, responded to the totemic argument of unity invoked by Leo XIV to uphold the canonical restrictions imposed by Traditionis Custodes, expressing a legitimate concern: “Unity is not an end in itself; it must always serve truth and the common good. By moving from the role of ‘guardians of the faith’ to that of ‘guarantors of unity’, bishops have opened the door to relativism and autocracy.”
The Risk of the Pontifical “Having It Both Ways”
During his remarks aboard the plane, Leo XIV took care to qualify his statement by adding: “Traditionis Custodes includes provisions for dispensations that allow Mass according to the Vetus Ordo to be celebrated”, before insisting: “There is a broad avenue available for those wishing to submit requests for dispensations.”
Is Leo XIV, through these words, seeking to accommodate both sides? During his visit to France, between his homily at Vespers in Notre-Dame de Paris and his address to the bishops of France, the Pope had employed much the same approach. “Be the conscious heirs of the Fathers and Saints of the Church who, throughout the centuries, have handed down to us the profound meaning and beauty of the liturgy, always bearing witness to great humility before the Mystery being celebrated.” These words could have suggested that those accustomed to the Vetus Ordo had nothing to reproach themselves for. Yet he went on to add: “Therefore, place communion with the Successor of Peter and with the Church before your personal sensibilities, so that you may cultivate the unity of the People of God.”
An injunction that leaves one struggling to determine whether it is a pointed remark directed at traditional Catholics or at liturgical initiatives that run counter to Roman directives.
Likewise, in Lourdes, Leo XIV reminded the bishops: “There have always been tensions throughout the history of the Church, but when they arise, that is precisely when we can appreciate the gift of unity all the more. This unity is not a flat uniformity, but rather allows every genuinely Catholic sensibility to converge naturally in a common profession of faith.”
A welcome intervention, yet qualified by a condition that leaves room for the most restrictive interpretations: “Subject to obedience to legitimate pastors, and in particular to the Successor of Peter. (…) A dynamic unity nourished by the Tradition of the Church — from the Fathers to the Second Vatican Council — and by the post-conciliar Magisterium.”
Here again, we find the same verbal “pas de deux” that the letter addressed to the bishops of France on 26 March 2026 had employed with virtuosity: “May the Holy Spirit inspire you with concrete solutions that would generously include those sincerely attached to the Vetus Ordo.” Words of openness immediately locked down by a “having it both ways” worthy of a triple Axel: “while respecting the orientations established by the Second Vatican Council regarding the liturgy.”
Is Leo XIV’s pontificate succumbing to Macronian vertigo, the politics of “having it both ways”? More elaborate liturgy at papal ceremonies, but at the same time catechesis on Vatican II and the benefits of liturgical reform. Speeches defending the traditional family, but at the same time appointments of bishops who publicly express their desire to see Rome revise its teaching precisely on the questions of priestly celibacy and the ordination of women!
From one pontificate to the next, the failure of the hermeneutic of continuity promoted by Benedict XVI in 2005 is plain to see. As for the specific question of the use of the Vetus Ordo, a casual observer might be tempted to speak of a dialogue of the deaf. Alas, let us be clear: that is not what we are witnessing. What we are being subjected to is something far worse: a gagged dialogue.
Representatives of the faithful and superiors of communities attached to the ancient form of the liturgy have never been invited to engage in sincere and courteous dialogue. The “reciprocal dialogue, rooted in faith and conducted in a synodal spirit” that Leo XIV praised before the bishops of France in Lourdes is denied to us. The promoters of Traditionis Custodes, in Rome and throughout the world, are resolutely standing in its way, concealing the truth from the Pope or distorting it for him. Probably both.
The Decline of the Church and Faith in Its Revival
Nevertheless, despite the headwinds, our hope remains undiminished, sustained by the serene conviction that the triumph of truth will ultimately shine forth. We are witnessing a widespread collapse — one in which there is no question of taking some morbid pleasure — amid the ashes of a reform that claimed to herald a new springtime but has ultimately seen the Church plunge into a long winter.
Despite the crowds surrounding Leo XIV with their fervour, the latest projections from the Pew Research Center, featured on the front page of La Croix last Thursday, 19 November, indeed predict that Muslims will become the world's largest religious group, overtaking Christians as early as 2035. An extraordinary shift, driven by a younger Muslim population with higher fertility rates than populations historically rooted in Christianity.
The zeal for souls and the passion for the glory of God are integral to the traditional Catholic family and explain its unwavering commitment to passing on the faith. To live the Gospel and spread it, to convert and be converted — in direct contrast to the recent remarks of Cardinal Vesco, who asserted that “We are not a proselytising Church, not a Church whose purpose is to convert” — this is the dearest aspiration of the faithful attached to the Vetus Ordo.
Will Pope Leo ever truly hear this quiet yet resolute cry of the little ones of the Church?



